Bethel

Church

of the Brethren

New Middletown, Ohio

in Mahoning County

Sunday Church Service

11:00 am

Black Left Arrow

Jesus Loving

Hymn Singing

Bible Teaching

Join us at Bethel Church of the Brethren on Sunday mornings at 11am in New Middletown, Ohio for our traditional one-hour service!

contact us

Contact

Rev David Wyant

Mailing Address

Bethel Church of the Brethren

4023 E Calla Rd

New Middletown, Ohio 44442

Email Address

bethel44442@gmail.com

Phone Number

330.542.3750

Service Time

11:00 am

My family has grown so much in the Lord at Bethel Church of the Brethren. The teaching is from the Bible and the people are kind.

– angela

I've been a member all my life and just love how the Bethel Church of the Brethren congregation cares for one-another. For me, loving Jesus is about loving people!

– diane

Studying the Bible has become easier for me as we learn together at Bethel Church of the Brethren. Reading verse by verse is helpful! I had never heard of expository (verse by verse) preaching before!

– ellagrace

Bethel Church of the Brethren proudly supports Rescue Mission of Mahoning Valley and Pregnancy Help Center

and hosts collections for both ministries during the year.

We would love to have you join us!

Bethel Church of the Brethren is a congregation full of community-minded people who love to serve the Lord and make disciples! We study the Bible with verse by verse preaching and sign hymns you'll remember from our hymn book. You'll feel welcome at Bethel Church of the Brethren.

Family Friendly

Verse By Verse Bible Teaching

kind and welcoming

Our History

Bethel Church of the Brethren, originally called the Dunkards, began its ministry in New Middletown, Ohio township in 1872.


The history of the church dates back to the eldership of Henry Kurtz and his care of the membership. Kurtz published the first church paper, named The Gospel Visitor for several years.





  • The Bethel Church of the Brethren church building was erected in 1873 on land donated by the Summers family. The land later became part of the Evans Lake.


  • The Bethel Church of the Brethren church house was moved to its present location on the corner of Unity and East Calla Roads in 1948.


  • Rev. James Ward was serving as the pastor on August 29, 1948 when the building and the new property was dedicated.


  • Among the 27 charter members were Joseph and Irene Snyder.


  • The Barth family donated the present Bethel Church of the Brethren church property (4023 E. Calla Rd) and in 1937 many new improvements were made to the building.


  • In 1956, a parsonage was built for Bethel Church of the Brethren on land donated by Mr. & Mrs. Cleo ODell.


  • Also in 1956, the first Bethel Church of the Brethren Vacation Bible School was organized. Hundreds of children enjoying the programs presented by director Ida Snyder Coy and her daughter Diane.


  • In 1977 a well was dug and an addition to the Bethel Church of the Brethren building was completed. With the much-appreciated inside plumbing, the original outhouse was moved to a Felger Road residence.


  • The addition brought new classroom space and in 1983 the original basement was partitioned for additional rooms. at Bethel Church of the Brethren.


  • A new Bethel Church of the Brethren sign was erected in 1996 and a steeple was placed on the roof in 1998.


  • Many faithful pastors have led the Bethel Church of the Brethren congregation in New Middletown Ohio since 1872. Currently, Rev. David Wyant is the pastor.


Milestones

Directions

4023 E Calla Rd.

New Middletown, Ohio

44442

Bethel Church of the Brethren is located in New Middletown Ohio at the intersection of Calla Rd and Unity Rd.


Just 18 minutes from Youngstown, Ohio

Directions from Youngstown:

  • 680 South to Exit 14 (E Western Reserve Rd)
  • At the traffic circle, take the 2nd exit onto Springfield Rd (travel 1.2 miles)
  • Turn left onto E Calla Rd. (travel 1.4 miles)
  • Church will be on your right just after Unity Rd


Just 19 minutes from Columbiana, Ohio

Directions from Columbiana

  • Take OH-164 N to Middletown Rd E (travel 6.2 miles)
  • Turn right onto Middletown Rd (travel 1.3 miles)
  • Turn left onto Springfield Rd (travel 1.3 miles)
  • Turn right on E Calla